When you sign up, you'll have the option to select from our two most recent Books of the Month:
Don't Say Mafia by C.R. Jane — A dark, addictive mafia romance featuring a down-on-her-luck FMC and an unhinged, sexy mobster MMC who will stop at nothing to have her.
Bonetide by Karina Halle — An atmospheric gothic romance filled with haunted waters, mysterious disappearances, and a dangerously hot stranger living across the loch.
Choose Your Subscription Tier
Both tiers include FREE US shipping and an exclusive special edition of our Book of the Month!
Good Girl — $25/month
Exclusive special edition Book of the Month
PS Book Club reading journal (included with your first box)
Book rating cards for your journal
Themed Book of the Month stickers
Book annotation tabs
Book annotation guide
FREE US shipping
Smut Slut — $40/month
Everything included in the Good Girl tier, PLUS:
Exclusive PS Book Club shirt (your first month includes our PS Book Club logo shirt!)
15% discount on purchases from the PS shop
FREE US shipping
A Few Important Things to Know
Limited availability: Book club spots are limited and offered on a first-come, first-served basis. We open as many spots as we can!
Your first payment: You'll be charged immediately upon signing up for your selected book and tier.
Your first shipment:Don't Say Mafia will ship this week, while Bonetide will ship closer to the end of October.
Your next renewal: Regardless of which book you choose, your next charge will be November 1st for November's Book of the Month, which will be announced soon.
Skipping: You cannot skip your initial book club selection. After your first month, you can manage your subscription and skip unlimited future months as you please.
Cancellations: You can cancel your subscription at any time, but payments already processed are final and nonrefundable. Canceled subscriptions cannot be reactivated; you'll need to sign up again when a new spot becomes available.
shipping & fulfillment
new book club members' orders ship after the fulfillment of all current members orders each month! we do our very best to get everyone the book in the feature month. please see our shipping updates page for the current status.
I love how the book was packaged. So much care. The stickers are so fun and match the books to a t. The review notebook is so nice and I'm excited to put it to use.
I am loving this Probably Smut book box subscription! I cannot wait to read this paperback! The shirt is perfect and I also love how the extra items match the book. 😍
My first box! I love that this subscription comes with cute stickers and tabs and a journal to log everything, it definitely separates it from other book subscriptions!!
Love! Received The Good Girls Probably Smut book Club on my birthday. The book is beautiful and everything it came with. I’m so excited. Already told everyone to join! Thank you!
This was the first box I got. I’ve wanted to get a subscription for a while and the fact that the box was C.R. Jane was icing on top as basically my favorite author. The box was still in tact when I received it and all items were still perfect. I was so excited to get the box!
First book so far and I’m in love! 😍 Everything was so thoughtful and right on theme with the book. Also the book is 100/10 must read especially for those who prefer morally grey or mafia romances!
I love books from Probably Smutt more than any other subscription site I’ve used. What you get for your money is so worth it and the books come shipped so nicely so you can be assured they won’t be ruined during transit.
I love how quickly my box came, and it was completely stress-free, and I was pleasantly surprised by everything in the box. It was simplistic but cute and functional!
A deliciously addictive read! Don’t Say Mafia by C.R. Jane had me hooked from the start. The chemistry, tension, twists, and dark romance made it impossible to put down. I loved the characters, the intensity, and the way the story kept me wanting more. Definitely a must-read for anyone who loves their romance dark, dangerous, and a little bit obsessive! ❤️🔥