100/10 obsessed ! I love the leading up to the spicy interactions between Sebastian and Quincy! I love their characters and the history they grew to have with each other! Overall one of my favorites, would no doubt read it again!

Mercedes D. 5/5 Verified September 26, 2026

good girl book club subscription

Stunning! Great addition to the series 😍

Cheryl A. 5/5 Verified September 25, 2026

PS Hardcover SE Prince of Swords by Elise Kova

Literal perfection couldn’t ask for more… but maybe one day we’ll get a sprayed edge!?

Brittany D. 5/5 Verified September 25, 2026

good girl book club subscription

Can’t wait to have the whole series!

Alixandria D. 5/5 Verified September 25, 2026

First-Time Caller by B.K. Borison

The collection keeps growing!

Alixandria D. 5/5 Verified September 25, 2026

good girl book club subscription

It’s beautiful!

Alixandria D. 5/5 Verified September 25, 2026

PS Hardcover SE Rites of the Starling by Devney Perry

I’m always so impressed with the covers and love how the stickers match the book and theme!

Bethany M. 5/5 Verified September 25, 2026

good girl book club subscription

I absolutely love having the page overlay option! I hope PS continues to offer this option.

Bethany M. 5/5 Verified September 25, 2026

In Stormy Weather Overlay Art Print

So happy to be able to have this as an add on! This book is just as gorgeous as the first and I so happy to have a matching set!

Meghan K. 5/5 Verified September 24, 2026

PS Hardcover SE Prince of Swords by Elise Kova

I loved the gold foiling on this book! Sooo pretty.

Meghan K. 5/5 Verified September 24, 2026

good girl book club subscription

Love the shirt! 🩷

Brandi L. 5/5 Verified September 24, 2026

watch hockey read smut be happy t-shirt

Sharing some with my cousin...need more space for MORE

Lillian P. 5/5 Verified September 24, 2026

romantasy sticker pack special

Absolutely LOVE them!!

Lillian P. 5/5 Verified September 24, 2026

books are a magical place to be sticker

She is beautiful and I love it so much 🥹

Elisabeth B. 5/5 September 24, 2026

romance reader book club

In love with overlays!!

Laura C. 5/5 Verified September 24, 2026

In Stormy Weather Overlay Art Print

Amazingggggggg ❤️❤️❤️

Silvia C. 5/5 Verified September 24, 2026

good girl book club subscription

I love PS subscription box. I unsubscribed recently and I wish I didn’t!

Ivy T. 5/5 Verified September 24, 2026

good girl book club subscription

Always the most beautiful books! Love the PS book club!

Madison G. 5/5 Verified September 24, 2026

good girl book club subscription

Probably Smut has the BEST overlays! The artwork is amazing, and the print quality is fantastic! They show up really well in the books!

Brandi S. 5/5 Verified September 24, 2026

In Stormy Weather Overlay Art Print

I absolutely love it!!! It was packaged so beautifully!! I was so excited to receive it! I wouldn’t change a thing! I received my box very quickly too!

Brittany A. 5/5 Verified September 23, 2026

good girl book club subscription

Phenomenal. Spectacular. Gimme all the books. I love it. Everything about it. The package. The app. The camaraderie. It’s everything I needed and wanted in a book club. 10/10 recommend.

Stella P. 5/5 Verified September 23, 2026

good girl book club subscription

One of the best book boxes I’ve ever been a part of — love every book I’ve received so far and you can tell how much care is put into every box and book. So stoked I found probably smut!

Hannah G. 5/5 Verified September 23, 2026

good girl book club subscription

I loved the box I received. It had cute stickers and flags that help coordinate with the themes you might want to flag. Loved it

Alexandra G. 5/5 Verified September 23, 2026

probably smut book club subscription

So excited to get this copy of In Stormy Weather!

Brianna S. 5/5 Verified September 22, 2026

probably smut book club subscription

So perfect

Brianna S. 5/5 Verified September 22, 2026

In Stormy Weather Overlay Art Print

I love my subscription! I look forward to it ever month.

Jude R. 5/5 Verified September 22, 2026

good girl book club subscription

Makes my day whenever my order arrives!

Brittany H. 5/5 Verified September 22, 2026

smut slut book club subscription

Such a beautiful book!! So excited to put her on my shelf.

Holly F. 5/5 Verified September 22, 2026

good girl book club subscription

I love the book, the annotation taps with bookmarks, stickers and the welcome book journal. 💕

Molly P. 5/5 Verified September 22, 2026

good girl book club subscription

Love the special edition books! It’s like a little treat each month!

Jennifer T. 5/5 Verified September 22, 2026

good girl book club subscription

Amazing Packaging, Beautiful Work! I’m excited for what’s the come!

Amanda R. 5/5 Verified September 22, 2026

good girl book club subscription

I love this book box, the books are beautiful and I love getting a new shirt that matches the book!

Frances R. 5/5 Verified September 21, 2026

smut slut book club subscription

Here is a video I posted

Shanna K. 5/5 Verified September 21, 2026

good girl book club subscription

Probably smut is a more unique book sub in which you get an exclusive cover but also an annotation guide with tabs as well as a journal and additional review pages once a month. A really fun subscription for someone interested in the analog trend or anyone who wants to get into annotating, each book comes with tabs and a color coded guide for what to tab. Really cool

Kyla P. 5/5 Verified September 21, 2026

good girl book club subscription

Amazing quality and service, and absolutely love the Illustrated cover of this one! So glad that I could get a copy of this in overstock and might have influenced a few more sales hehe

Bettina M. 5/5 Verified September 20, 2026

No Pucks by J.R. Gray - SE paperback bundle

Loved it

Rendi P. 5/5 Verified September 20, 2026

[IMPERFECT] Mountain Boss by S.J. Tilly - SE paperback

Loved the shirt and shipped fast!!!

Rendi P. 5/5 Verified September 20, 2026

my favorite color is morally gray t-shirt

As soon as I so the teaser, I knew it was in stormy weather and I love it so much. The design is beautiful and the cover is so gorgeous🥰🥰 and the overlay🥵🥵🥵

Ashley F. 5/5 Verified September 20, 2026

good girl book club subscription

I love this subscription! I feel like it’s a great price for what you get. I love the packaging, and how everything is packed. I would 10/10 recommend to someone who loves reading 🥰

Megan W. 5/5 Verified September 20, 2026

smut slut book club subscription

Love these stickers for my clear kindle case!

Dannielle C. 5/5 Verified September 19, 2026

morally gray sticker pack special